I don't buy the "never clean your finds" rule, I rinse mine at the tap and my pottery sherds are still fine
For my first two seasons digging at a site outside Tucson I followed the old rule and only dry brushed everything, which meant my bags of plain brownware sherds sat dusty for months and I could not sort them by temper or surface treatment. Last spring I started giving the really tough, undecorated body sherds a quick rinse under low tap water and letting them air dry on a towel for a day, and out of maybe 300 pieces not one crumbled or lost its paste color. I get why people warn against it for painted or fragile stuff, and I still never touch those, but for plain utilitarian ware the dry brush was just hiding what I needed to see. Your mileage may vary with your soil and clay type, but has anyone else tried a gentle wash on plain sherds and had it go wrong?