8
Unpopular opinion: I thought my buttercream was smooth until I saw a video from a baker in Portland.
I realized my whole 'room temp' butter was actually still too cold after my 5th batch of grainy frosting, so do you think texture is more about feel or a strict temp reading?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
cameronschmidt1mo agoTop Commenter
My buttercream was a gritty mess for years until I finally bought a cheap thermometer.
6
simonb921mo ago
A thermometer took my buttercream from sad sugary paste to actual frosting. Adam's right that feel matters but it's not either/or. You can check the temp and still know the butter's tackiness under your thumb. The real secret is combining both. Once you know what 68 degrees feels like you can ditch the thermometer later. But starting without one is like learning guitar on a broken fret. You need the crutch until the skill sticks.
3
You ever think maybe we're overcomplicating this? A strict temp reading seems like baking by numbers, not by feel. My best results come from knowing the butter's give under my thumb, not from a digital readout. That Portland baker's method works for their kitchen, their butter, their climate. Relying on a tool takes you out of the process. The feel in your hands is the real feedback loop, not a screen.
4