10
First time I matched crown molding across two rooms and it actually lined up
Spent 3 hours last Saturday fussing with the angle finder on a 15 year old house where nothing is square, but the seam came out so clean you can't even feel it with your finger. Anybody else find that older houses fight back way harder than new construction?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
paulschmidt1mo ago
My 1950s house has studs that are 18 inches apart in some spots, so I feel you on the "nothing is square" thing. But I actually think older houses are way more forgiving than new builds because the wood has had decades to settle and the drywall compound is usually harder. That fresh MDF trim in a new development, man, that stuff moves with the humidity like a snake. I'd rather fudge miters on old plaster any day than fight brand new house wrap that traps moisture and makes everything warp. What year is your place exactly?
1
ellis.hayden1mo ago
Gotta push back on that one hard. My buddy just finished gutting a 1920s bungalow and that old wood was so dried out and brittle it snapped like toothpicks when he tried to nail anything into it. Plus that ancient plaster? One wrong move with a saw and you're staring at a crack that runs all the way to the ceiling. I'd take a fresh new build with OSB and drywall any day, even if it has some MDF trim that swells up a little in August. At least you know the framing is straight and the house wrap actually keeps the moisture out instead of letting it wick right through old lathe and horsehair plaster.
8
jamie_smith1mo ago
Yeah, the wood being brittle is a real pain, but I think there's a bigger issue nobody's brought up yet - the old growth lumber in those 1920s houses was actually way denser and more rot resistant than the fast grown stuff they use now. @ellis.hayden you're right about the plaster being tricky, but that old wood still has more structural integrity than an OSB panel that turns to mush if a pipe ever leaks. Honestly, I'd rather deal with a few snapped nails than worry about my new build crumbling after one bad rain.
2