19
My brother-in-law said 'just replace the board' and it made me mad at first, but now I'm not so sure.
He's not even in the trade, he's a project manager. We were at a family thing and I was complaining about a 5-year-old Samsung TV with a bad power supply. I said I'd spent two evenings trying to find the exact blown capacitor. He just shrugged and said, 'For the time you're putting in, you could have just ordered the whole board for $40 and been done.' I argued about the principle of the thing, fixing the root cause, not being wasteful. But later, I thought about it. For a customer paying by the hour, is it really better to bill them for 3 hours of diagnostic and micro-soldering versus 1 hour for a swap? I still love the puzzle of component-level repair, but maybe he has a point for certain jobs. When do you guys draw the line between a proper fix and a practical swap?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
matthew_hart2521d agoTop Commenter
Wait, he said the whole board was only forty bucks? That changes everything. For that price, swapping it is the only sane move. You can't even buy the parts for that cheap.
3
felix_henderson5421d ago
Ever had a board where the fault was just a pain to find? I spent a whole weekend on a monitor once... then saw the replacement board was like thirty bucks. Felt dumb, but just swapped it.
3
Thirty bucks for a new board" is why I stopped fixing old laptop motherboards.
2