Can we settle this: is the roommate scorecard petty or smart?
My roommate leaves dishes in the sink for 3 or 4 days at a time, so I started keeping a little tally on the fridge whiteboard, just check marks next to stuff like dishes, trash, and loud video games after midnight. Part of me thinks it's fair because after 2 weeks of marks he actually cleaned up without me saying a word, which never happened when I just asked him nicely. The other part of me feels like a jerk every time I grab a marker, and last Tuesday he saw me adding a mark and said "so we're keeping score now?" and the room got real quiet. I get why it looks childish, but nagging him every night was making me miserable and this took the edge off. So here's the debate: is a visible tally a real fix or just a passive aggressive move that builds up bad feelings? My girlfriend says scorecards ruin relationships, but my brother swears it saved his apartment. What would you pick, the whiteboard or a sit-down talk?