That time a librarian told me to stop doing book displays by genre
She said my mystery section was "confusing" because I lumped true crime in with cozy mysteries, so now I separate them by tone and mood instead. Has anyone else gotten pushback on how they organize something they thought was obvious?
Play devil's advocate here but I think your librarian had a point. Genre sorting is already a mess because people disagree on where books belong - like how some folks classify Stephen King as horror while others call it thriller. What happens when a customer wants a "light read" and grabs a true crime book thinking it's a cozy mystery? They'd be disappointed and maybe blame the library for bad organization. Mood and tone sorting might work for bookstores with staff who know their stock but in a public library with different patrons it just creates more confusion than it solves.
Ngl, "mildly confused" is basically my permanent state after any trip to IKEA, so at least you're consistent. 😂 Maybe we need Dewey Decimal for moods now, like a 101.3 for "existential dread meets light comedy.